Sugar Creek Homes under $400,000

Sugar Creek Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Sugar Creek, Indiana—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Hoosier State, where small-town charm meets modern convenience. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Sugar Creek offers a serene lifestyle that appeals to families, retirees, and everyone in between. With its lush parks, scenic walking trails, and vibrant local businesses, this quaint town is perfect for those seeking a peaceful retreat without sacrificing access to urban amenities.

One of the standout features of Sugar Creek is its diverse real estate market, particularly for homes priced under $400,000. Here, you’ll find a variety of options that cater to different tastes and lifestyles. From charming single-family homes with spacious yards to modern townhouses with contemporary finishes, there’s something for everyone. Many homes boast beautiful architecture, inviting interiors, and well-maintained outdoor spaces, making them perfect for both entertaining and relaxation.

Living in Sugar Creek means enjoying a tight-knit community where neighbors become friends. The local schools are highly rated, ensuring that families have access to quality education. Additionally, residents can enjoy seasonal festivals, farmers' markets, and community events that foster a sense of belonging.

With its affordable housing options and exceptional quality of life, Sugar Creek is not just a place to live; it's a place to thrive. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or looking to downsize, this charming region invites you to discover the warmth and beauty of Sugar Creek, Indiana. Come explore your future home today!

Newest Sugar Creek Homes under $400,000

2814 W Walnut Drive, Greenfield
$255,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Serene setting on .57 acre lot in New Palestine Schools. Updated throughout this three bedroom two bath ranch is just what you've been looking for. Lots of bright sunlight enters the home through the new windows. Cooks dream kitchen. Beautiful granite countertops offer lots of working counter space. The center island overlooks all the living spaces in this open floor plan. All appliances included even washer/dryer. NEW FURNACE AND AC in 2024 This will be a great place to spend your summers enjoying country life. Image seeing the stars in the sky without bright city lights. Best thing is there is NO HOA!

2814 W Walnut Drive, Greenfield

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

7141 Lillian Place, Cumberland
$258,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Have you been looking for Easy Living! If you've been looking for a home that gives you more time to enjoy life and less time doing yard work, take a look at this one. Built in 2022, this 2-bedroom, 2-bath villa in Cumberland offers the best of low-maintenance living with a little something extra. You'll love the open-concept layout, cozy fireplace turns off with a flick of a switch, 2-car attached garage, main-level laundry, and time back for you to actually enjoy the home. The sunroom/flex space might just be the favorite spot in the house-perfect for your morning coffee, working from home, or cute sitting area. There's also a separate den/office that gives you room for a home office, some have converted this room into a 3rd bedroom! The primary suite offers a private bath and HUGE walk-in closet, with a second bedroom and full bath for guests. And the best part? The exterior maintenance is handled for you, so you can spend your time enjoying the home instead of taking care of it. With an acceptable offer, the seller is willing to offer buyer concessions or 1 year of Prorated HOA dues. 7141 Lillian Pl isn't just another villa-it's a chance to simplify without settling. Come take a look!

7141 Lillian Place, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Home Bound Real Estate LLC.

5478 W Boggstown Road, Boggstown
$179,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
If you've been dreaming of a farmhouse in the country, look no further. This 3bedroom, 2bath home sits on 1.53 acres and offers the peaceful rural setting you've been searching for. Positioned on a corner lot surrounded by open fields, the property features mature trees and plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors. A great collection of outbuildings adds versatility and function: a large pole barn with 3+ car garage/workshop space, a shed, a wellhouse, and a small barn-ideal for storage, hobbies, or small livestock (chickens) The home itself offers a classic farmhouse feel and is ready for your personal touch. Some updates are needed, giving you the opportunity to make it your own and bring out its full potential. A country property with room to grow, space to breathe, and endless possibilities.

5478 W Boggstown Road, Boggstown

Listing courtesy of The Property Shop of Indiana.

6205 W 300 S Road S, New Palestine
$297,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Some homes just feel right the moment you arrive. Nestled in the charming community of New Palestine, just a short drive from Indianapolis, this sweet two-bedroom charmer sits on a generous .59-acre lot and delivers that rare combination, the unhurried feeling of small town living with easy access to everything the city offers. The newly improved 600 South corridor opens up a lovely path to the public schools and the beloved Pennsy Trail - a wonderful bonus for walkers, cyclists, and families alike. You'll love this home with its loads of updates! The kitchen is a delight, light and airy, appointed with white cabinetry, updated countertops, a wall oven, cooktop, and direct access to the deck. The dining room offers full windows overlooking the backyard with space for a desk or a cherished plant collection, a room that functions well. A warm and inviting family room offers easy access to the backyard, making indoor and outdoor living feel effortlessly connected. The primary bedroom leads to a surprisingly beautiful updated bath featuring a full tiled shower, new counter & sink, and walk-in closet. A genuine upgrade you might not expect at this price point. A two-year-old deck with wrought iron-style railings invites you to linger. And then there is the barn, a proper little red barn with white cross doors, lovingly rebuilt and expanded with a handsome covered lean-to supported by timbers that give it real presence and shelter. Honestly, it might be your most favorite thing about the property! The unfinished basement offers excellent storage and laundry hookups, with additional stackable connections available in the main level hall closet. You will not believe all the updates; too numerous to list here. Lovingly maintained and quietly waiting, with a full updates sheet available. Some houses are just houses. This one feels like home.

6205 W 300 S Road S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

4860 W Safford Drive, New Palestine
$398,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Some homes simply give you more space. This one gives you more ways to live. With 5 bedrooms, 3.5 baths and more than 3,100 sq ft, this New Palestine home was made for life's changing seasons whether that means a growing household, welcoming family under one roof, working from home or simply having room for everyone to feel at home. A main-level bedroom and full bath offer comfortable space for guests or extended family, while the flexible front room can become the office, playroom or dining room that fits your life. The kitchen and great room are where life naturally comes together. The large island becomes the place for morning coffee, quick breakfasts, homework and conversations while dinner is being made. Quartz countertops, updated appliances, tile backsplash, generous pantry storage, crown molding, fresh paint and thoughtful updates make the home feel both welcoming and ready to enjoy. Step outside and you may find your favorite place. Thoughtful landscaping and a spacious patio create a backyard oasis for quiet mornings, summer dinners and evenings spent with family and friends. With no immediate neighbor behind or beside the home and open common space beyond, there's a wonderful sense of openness that's hard to appreciate until you see it. Upstairs, everyone has room to spread out with a spacious loft, 4 generously sized bedrooms, large closets and the convenience of an upstairs laundry room. The primary suite offers a comfortable place to unwind, complete with double vanities and a walk-in closet with custom shelving. Copperstone adds even more to everyday life with sidewalks, a community pool and playground. It's a home with room to gather, room to grow and room for whatever comes next.

4860 W Safford Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

255 Holly Lane, Greenfield
$329,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
The Aria II is a thoughtfully designed 1,601-square-foot single-story ranch home that masterfully blends modern open-concept living with functional private spaces. The heart of the home is a bright, spacious great room that flows seamlessly into the dining area and kitchen. Perfect for entertaining, the kitchen features a large counter-height island with casual bar seating, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a walk-in pantry. Designed with a popular split-bedroom layout, the Aria II prioritizes privacy. The luxurious primary suite is tucked away at the rear of the home, offering a quiet sanctuary complete with a generous walk-in closet and an ensuite bathroom with a double-sink vanity. On the opposite side of the home, two additional bedrooms share a second full bathroom, making them ideal for kids, guests, or a home office. Large windows throughout fill the entire home with natural light. Practical features include a dedicated laundry room positioned near the attached two-car garage for a smooth daily transition. Outdoor living is highlighted by a covered rear porch, extending your usable space into the backyard for dining and relaxation. Complete with smart home technology, this efficient layout beautifully caters to a wide range of lifestyles. Photos are representative of the plan and may vary.

255 Holly Lane, Greenfield

Listing courtesy of DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC.

6349 W Buckskin Court, New Palestine
$315,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Room to spread out, settle in, and enjoy more space inside and out at 6349 W Buckskin Ct in New Palestine. Situated on just over half an acre, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offers 1,822 square feet of comfortable single-level living with a layout built for everyday functionality. Inside, the home offers generous living spaces with plenty of flexibility for relaxing, gathering, working from home, or creating a space that fits your lifestyle. Three bedrooms provide versatility for sleeping, guests, hobbies, or a dedicated home office, while two full bathrooms keep the floor plan practical and convenient. Outside is where the possibilities really expand. The more than half-acre lot provides plenty of room for outdoor entertaining, gardening, recreation, or simply enjoying a backyard with breathing room. Whether your vision includes evenings around a fire pit, weekend cookouts, or creating your own outdoor retreat, there's space to make it happen. With its ranch-style layout, spacious lot, and New Palestine location, 6349 W Buckskin Ct offers the combination of indoor comfort and outdoor space that's becoming increasingly difficult to find.

6349 W Buckskin Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC.

219 Springfield Crossing, Greenfield
$295,540
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to the Greensboro by D.R. Horton, America's Builder, an exceptional quick move-in home nestled in Greenfield, IN. Designed with an impeccable balance of style and functionality, this two-story layout features 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and a versatile floor plan tailored for modern living. Step through the welcoming foyer to discover a flexible downstairs den, perfect for a quiet home office. The main floor opens into an expansive great room that flows seamlessly into the dining area and a chef-inspired kitchen, creating an inviting environment for hosting guests or relaxing. The stunning kitchen boasts ample cabinet storage, premium quartz countertops, a convenient breakfast bar, and a walk-in pantry. Upstairs, a generous loft offers a perfect space for a secondary living zone, media room, or playroom. The peaceful primary suite serves as your private retreat, featuring an oversized walk-in closet and a spa-like ensuite bathroom complete with a double vanity sink, beautifully tiled shower, dedicated linen storage, and a private commode. Enjoy outdoor living on the open back patio, complemented by a sleek rear-load garage. Additionally, every D.R. Horton home comes fully equipped with America's Smart Home technology-including a video doorbell, Honeywell thermostat, smart door lock, and a Deako lighting package. Photos are representative of plan and may vary as built.

219 Springfield Crossing, Greenfield

Listing courtesy of DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC.

5311 W 300 S, New Palestine
$282,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Set on 0.62 acres in New Palestine, this well-maintained brick ranch offers the space, privacy, and single-level living buyers are looking for. With 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 1,577 square feet, the home features a spacious living room anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, an eat-in kitchen with breakfast bar, and a welcoming foyer. The primary suite includes a walk-in closet and private bath with a separate tub and shower, while two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, enjoy a large fully fenced backyard with plenty of room to entertain, garden, play, or simply relax beneath the mature trees. A mini barn adds convenient extra storage, and the attached finished 2-car garage provides even more functionality. With no HOA and more than half an acre, there is room to spread out without giving up convenient access to New Palestine and the Southern Hancock County school system. Whether you're drawn to the classic brick exterior, generous yard, cozy fireplace, or easy ranch-style floor plan, this property offers a comfortable place to call home with space both inside and out.

5311 W 300 S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Mark Dietel Realty, LLC.

322 Oak Street, Thorntown
$249,500
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
In a quiet neighborhood in Thorntown, you'll find this perfect home. Offering nearly 1100 sq ft of living space that is updated and ready for you to enjoy. The kitchen is thoughtfully equipped with a functional island, providing both workspace and a casual dining area. Among the three inviting bedrooms, one stands out with a distinct accent wall, adding a touch of personality and character to the space. There is a lot of 'new' here, all in last three years. Improvements include the asphalt driveway, Leaf Guard gutter and downspout system, attic insulation, garage door and opener, a new water softener, as well as a painting refresh and new flooring. Beyond the interior, this home offers a large private yard, perfect for outdoor enjoyment and relaxation, which you can access through the extra-large sunroom. An attached garage provides convenience and secure parking, and a welcoming porch invites you to unwind. For added practicality, a dedicated laundry room simplifies household chores. Thorntown has much to offer, and location is Western Boone schools district.

322 Oak Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams-Morrison.

6615 W State Road 47, Thorntown
$329,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Completely Renovated Ranch on 1 Acre! Enjoy the best of both worlds with this beautifully remodeled home nestled on a spacious 1 acre lot just on the edge of town! Step inside to a brand new kitchen featuring soft close cabinetry, stunning quartz countertops, and new SS appliances. Extensive updates include a new 200 amp electrical panel, new plumbing, new flooring throughout the home, an updated gravel driveway, and more! With thoughtful design from top to bottom and plenty of outdoor space to enjoy, this move in ready property offers the perfect blend of modern comfort, country charm, and a convenient location. Don't miss your opportunity to make this refreshed home your own!

6615 W State Road 47, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Branch Realty.

7021 Lillian Place, Cumberland
$259,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

7021 Lillian Place, Cumberland

Listing courtesy of Totalis Real Estate Solutions.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative