Butler Tarkington Real Estate

Butler Tarkington Real Estate

Welcome to Butler Tarkington, a charming and vibrant neighborhood nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Indiana. This delightful subdivision, located in Marion County, offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, making it an ideal place for families, young professionals, and retirees alike.

Butler Tarkington is known for its tree-lined streets, historic homes, and a strong sense of community. The area boasts a rich architectural diversity, with beautiful residences ranging from stately brick homes to cozy bungalows, each exuding character and charm. As you stroll through the neighborhood, you'll find meticulously maintained gardens and welcoming front porches, perfect for enjoying warm Indiana evenings.

One of the standout features of Butler Tarkington is its proximity to Butler University, which not only enriches the community with its vibrant student life but also offers a variety of cultural events, sporting activities, and educational opportunities. The neighborhood is also conveniently located near popular shopping districts, local eateries, and parks, providing residents with a wealth of options for recreation and relaxation.

Families will appreciate the highly-rated schools in the area, as well as the numerous parks and green spaces that invite outdoor activities. Whether you’re enjoying a leisurely walk, having a picnic, or engaging in community events, Butler Tarkington fosters a welcoming atmosphere that encourages connections among neighbors.

Embrace the charm and community spirit of Butler Tarkington, where a perfect blend of historic elegance and modern living awaits you. Discover your dream home in this delightful Indianapolis neighborhood today!

Newest Listings in Butler Tarkington

5305 Cornelius Avenue, Indianapolis
$475,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Good living in Butler-Tarkington. Nestled on a quiet street, on a nearly quarter-acre lot with lovely trees and perennials, this 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath home has plenty of room to gather. A cathedral ceiling, skylights, and two sets of French doors make the great room feel especially bright and airy. With room for both a seating area and a dining table, plus a pass-through to the kitchen, it's ready for holiday dinners and lazy Sunday mornings alike. The newly updated kitchen features white Shaker-style cabinets, quartz countertops, and stainless steel appliances. Hardwood floors and dormer windows give the bedrooms an extra touch of charm, and there's generous closet space, too. On the lower level, the finished family room is a cozy spot for movie night, while the unfinished side of the basement offers plenty of storage. Take your morning coffee out to the covered front porch or settle in on one of two brick patios. An attached garage is convenient for upcoming winter weather. The Central Canal Towpath is less than a block away for a walk or bike ride into Broad Ripple or a longer ride downtown. Wander through Holcomb Gardens on Butler's campus, grab a bite at Chatham Tap, or head to 56th & Illinois for coffee, ice cream, dinner, groceries, and a plethora of specialty shops. Spend summers swimming at the nearby Rivi. Welcome home!

5305 Cornelius Avenue, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Kelly Lavengood. Good Living Indy, LLC
5047 Graceland Avenue, Indianapolis
$425,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Located in the heart of Indianapolis's historic Butler-Tarkington neighborhood, this four-bedroom brick cottage perfectly blends classic architectural character with modern convenience. A paneled foyer opens into an inviting living room, where a paneled fireplace wall serves as a cozy focal point. The main floor features an ideal layout for entertaining, flowing seamlessly into a formal dining room perfect for dinner parties or family meals, as well as a partially updated kitchen. Two main-floor bedrooms and a full bath round out the lower level. Upstairs, you'll find two additional spacious bedrooms alongside a second full bath that was completely renovated within the past five years. The screened patio is ideal for outdoor dining. A full unfinished basement provides excellent storage or a clean canvas for future living space. Beautiful hardwood floors throughout. 2 car detached garage. All of this within walking distance to Butler University, neighborhood shops and restaurants.

5047 Graceland Avenue, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Michael Johnson. Encore Sotheby's International
5350 N Kenwood Avenue, Indianapolis
$595,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Turnkey charmer with architectural details and myriad of upgrades in wonderfully walkable neighborhood. All brick with arches, niches, crown molding, newly-refinished hardwoods and doors. A chef's kitchen with large granite island, tons of counter and cabinets. Dining room with wine frig, buffet bar. Hang stockings with care on limestone (decorative) fireplace. Finished lower level with family room and 4th bedroom, newer full bath. All 4 bedrooms have space!! New 2nd floor bath with basketweave tile floor, walk-in shower yet keeping the period look of built-in cabinets. Thermal windows and 50-yr architectural 3D roof. Raspberries, milkweed (monarchs) & pollinator garden. Hot tub stays. Concrete drive! Oversized 2 car. Sewer and water supply lines replaced. New furnace and a/c July 2026. Enjoy the ambiance.

5350 N Kenwood Avenue, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Pegg Kennedy. F.C. Tucker Company
4653 N Illinois Street, Indianapolis
$764,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Just re-listed after recent improvements! | Completely remodeled from top to bottom, this stunning home is nestled on a deep, tree-lined lot backing up to the Governor's Residence & just blocks from neighborhood dining, shopping, parks & schools. Fresh exterior updates (including new siding, new roof, exterior paint, professional landscaping & privacy fence) create exceptional curb appeal. Inside, timeless character blends seamlessly with modern conveniences. A traditional staircase, two fireplaces, refinished hardwood floors, built-ins & exposed brick add warmth & charm. Newer vinyl windows flood the home with natural light & tranquil, park-like views. The spacious formal living room flows effortlessly into a chef-inspired eat-in kitchen featuring quartz countertops, a large breakfast bar, a serving station & thoughtfully selected designer finishes. At the rear of the home, a rare second living area provides the perfect space to relax or entertain. Built-in cubbies & a stylish half bath add convenience to the main level. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite offers a walk-in closet & an ensuite bath complete with a custom tiled walk-in shower. Two additional bedrooms share a generous full bath featuring a double vanity & tiled tub/shower. The finished lower level adds even more flexible living space with a large rec room for movie nights or game days, a dedicated laundry room & a private fourth bedroom with its own ensuite bath - ideal for guests, in-laws, or a home office. A separate utility room provides abundant storage. Outside, enjoy the fully fenced backyard, complete with mature trees, a charming paver patio & access to a detached two-car garage. A generous driveway provides ample off-street parking for guests. Beautifully updated, full of character & ideally located, this is the perfect place to call home!

4653 N Illinois Street, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Chanda Johnson. Maywright Property Co.
4075 Byram Avenue, Indianapolis
$204,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Completely updated 3 bedroom 2 bath all brick ranch minutes from Butler University. Stunning curb appeal. Home includes new pex plumbing, new HVAC system and new Pella Vinyl windows. New insulated garage door with remote and key pad. New dimensional shingled roof, New kitchen cabinets with quartz countertops, New stainless steel appliances, and glistening ceiling fan in breakfast area. All new upgraded 200 AMP electrical system, New luxury vinyl plank flooring, New Sherwin Williams paint throughout, New doors. Bathrooms are all new and tastefully done with new vanities, lighting, and fixtures. Oversized attached garage plumbed for washer and dryer. Move in and do nothing! Turnkey.

4075 Byram Avenue, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Gary Bieberich. List4Less Executive Homes
Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!