Butler Tarkington Homes for Sale

Butler Tarkington Homes for Sale

Welcome to Butler Tarkington, one of Indianapolis' most charming and sought-after neighborhoods, nestled in the heart of Marion County. This vibrant community, known for its picturesque tree-lined streets and historic homes, offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience. With its rich architectural diversity, Butler Tarkington features everything from elegant bungalows to stately Tudor-style residences, making it a perfect fit for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

Living in Butler Tarkington means embracing a lifestyle filled with culture and leisure. Residents enjoy easy access to a variety of parks, including the expansive Butler University campus and the scenic Holcomb Gardens, perfect for leisurely strolls or weekend picnics. The neighborhood is also home to an array of local shops, delightful cafes, and fine dining options, ensuring that everything you need is just a stone's throw away.

For those considering a move, there are a number of homes for sale in Butler Tarkington that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. Whether you're looking for a cozy starter home or a spacious property with character, the current real estate offerings in this area promise to meet your needs. With its strong sense of community, excellent schools, and proximity to downtown Indianapolis, Butler Tarkington is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Come discover the charm and warmth of Butler Tarkington—your dream home awaits!

Newest Butler Tarkington Homes for Sale

$299,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Charming Storybook Tudor Revival on One of Indy's Most Prestigious Streets ~ Nestled four blocks from the Governor's Mansion on Illinois Street ~ a tree-lined address that carries the same prestige as Washington Blvd., Pennsylvania Avenue, or Meridian Street ~ this 1920 Tudor Revival cottage offers timeless character in an unbeatable location. ~ Set back beneath a canopy of century old trees, this home is framed by a fenced yard, small garden path, wood deck and an attached garage, blending curb appeal with everyday conveniences. Step through the graceful arched front entry into a home that has preserved its original architectural soul: hand-crafted hardwood floors, textured stucco walls & ceilings, iron handrails, a classic wood burning fireplace, original interior doors, and charming arched doorways carry the character of the 1920's throughout. The windows, kitchen and bathrooms have been thoughtfully updated for modern living, striking the perfect balance between vintage charm and everyday comfort. Outside, a private deck overlooking a secluded yard is perfect for entertaining, and the open patio with pathway provides the perfect space for your herb garden. Location is second to none, walkable to neighborhood parks, next to elementary school and walkable to Butler University, plus a bus ride to downtown Indy just moments away. This is Butler Tarkington living at its finest: historic character, an unmatched address and true walkable convenience.

4050 N Illinois Street, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Nix Real Estate Group.

$455,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Located in the heart of Indianapolis's historic Butler-Tarkington neighborhood, this four-bedroom brick cottage perfectly blends classic architectural character with modern convenience. A paneled foyer opens into an inviting living room, where a paneled fireplace wall serves as a cozy focal point. The main floor features an ideal layout for entertaining, flowing seamlessly into a formal dining room perfect for dinner parties or family meals, as well as a partially updated kitchen. Two main-floor bedrooms and a full bath round out the lower level. Upstairs, you'll find two additional spacious bedrooms alongside a second full bath that was completely renovated within the past five years. The screened patio is ideal for outdoor dining. A full unfinished basement provides excellent storage or a clean canvas for future living space. Beautiful hardwood floors throughout. 2 car detached garage. All of this within walking distance to Butler University, neighborhood shops and restaurants.

5047 Graceland Avenue, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Encore Sotheby's International.

$595,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Turnkey charmer with architectural details and myriad of upgrades in wonderfully walkable neighborhood. All brick with arches, niches, crown molding, newly-refinished hardwoods and doors. A chef's kitchen with large granite island, tons of counter and cabinets. Dining room with wine frig, buffet bar. Hang stockings with care on limestone (decorative) fireplace. Finished lower level with family room and 4th bedroom, newer full bath. All 4 bedrooms have space!! New 2nd floor bath with basketweave tile floor, walk-in shower yet keeping the period look of built-in cabinets. Thermal windows and 50-yr architectural 3D roof. Raspberries, milkweed (monarchs) & pollinator garden. Hot tub stays. Concrete drive! Oversized 2 car. Sewer and water supply lines replaced. New furnace and a/c July 2026. Enjoy the ambiance.

5350 N Kenwood Avenue, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$204,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Completely updated 3 bedroom 2 bath all brick ranch minutes from Butler University. Stunning curb appeal. Home includes new pex plumbing, new HVAC system and new Pella Vinyl windows. New insulated garage door with remote and key pad. New dimensional shingled roof, New kitchen cabinets with quartz countertops, New stainless steel appliances, and glistening ceiling fan in breakfast area. All new upgraded 200 AMP electrical system, New luxury vinyl plank flooring, New Sherwin Williams paint throughout, New doors. Bathrooms are all new and tastefully done with new vanities, lighting, and fixtures. Oversized attached garage plumbed for washer and dryer. Move in and do nothing! Turnkey. Could be Census tract eligible for grants to help either closing costs, pre-paid, interest rate buy down and in some cases down payment assistance. Call Matthew Belsley at PNC Bank for details. 317.420.6685

4075 Byram Avenue, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of List4Less Executive Homes.

$435,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
This darling Cape Cod, tucked away on a quiet street in Butler-Tarkington, is ready to welcome its next owners! Ideally located near Butler University, neighborhood parks & local dining, with easy access to the interstate, downtown & the north side. The exterior was just repainted & has a brand new roof! Inside, the thoughtfully updated interior blends modern amenities with timeless character, including transom windows & original moldings. Fresh renovations shine throughout, with refinished hardwood floors on the main level, all-new paint & updated fixtures. Generous windows fill the home with natural light, creating a bright & inviting atmosphere. The formal living room flows seamlessly into the dining area through a graceful archway, where a charming bay window & French doors add warmth & interest. The fully updated kitchen features brand new cabinetry, quartz countertops with a breakfast bar, a stylish tile backsplash & a stainless steel appliance package. A rare main-level bedroom with an attached full bathroom offers flexible living - perfect as a private guest suite, home office, or den! Upstairs, 2 oversized bedrooms each feature multiple closets, ceiling fans, brand new carpet & beautifully updated ensuite bathrooms. A convenient laundry closet is located just outside the upstairs bedrooms. Outside, relax or entertain on the spacious Trex deck overlooking the fully fenced & landscaped backyard. A brand new 20x25 garage provides ample space for 2 vehicles plus storage. There's even more storage available in the unfinished basement & backyard shed. New HVAC and water heater, too! Offering the perfect blend of character, updates & location, this is a home you won't want to miss!

4062 Rookwood Avenue, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Maywright Property Co..

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative